We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
We updated this article in June 2022 to include additional information about each featured product selected by the Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab and expert commentary on the most effective nail strengthener. We removed one out of stock product and a new pick from Zoya.
Weak, brittle, peeling nails are a fact of life: According to the American Academy of Dermatology, 20% of people have brittle nails (they are more likely to occur in woman over 60, but anyone can develop the condition). Nails can become brittle and weak and start to chip or peel due to prolonged exposure to water via hand washing, gel nail polish removal or even habits like nail picking and biting. That's where nail strengtheners come in: These products help to fortify cuticles and harden nails, protecting them from peeling and breaking with regular use over time.
To find the best of the best, the Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab tests hundreds of beauty products, including nail polishes and press-on nails, every year. In a recent GH Beauty Lab, we polled our over 1,300 panelists for their favorite products that help combat brittleness and keep nails looking their best. Ahead, you will find the best nail strengthener and hardeners that really work, including GH Beauty Lab test winners, editor picks and GH tester panelists' go-to formulas:
Our top picks:
Most Popular Nail Strengthener on Amazon
Onyx Professional Hard As Hoof Nail Strengthening Cream
Read more
For more info on how to find the most effective nail strengthener and more shopping tips, scroll to the bottom of this article, then learn how to get your healthiest nails (including investing in a great cuticle cream and nourishing hand cream!).
Pros
- Increases nail density
- Smooths the appearance of nails
- Absorbs quickly
Cons
- Requires a 4 week commitment
Unlike other nail hardeners that are more like lacquers, this Good Housekeeping Beauty Award winner has a serum-like texture that absorbs quickly into nails without leaving any film or coating on nails. It has been clinically shown to significantly improve the appearance, roughness, and thickness of nails in 28 days, when applied daily. Consumers also noted positive improvements in smoothness and found nails were harder in four weeks.
Pros
- Budget-friendly
- Glossy coating
- Prevents nail damage
Cons
This tried and true drugstore formula from Sally Hansen, originally developed in 1957, has definitely stood the test of time with our panel voting it their favorite nail strengthener. “I've been using it for years and it seems to do a great job of keeping my nails hard,” one panelist marveled. Film formers, like nitrocellulose, impart a hard, glossy barrier on the nail preventing it from any damage. It's available in two variants of clear and tinted, which can help lessen the look of discoloration.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Moisturizes nails
- Easily absorbs
Cons
- Needs multiple applications a day
Not only is Hard As Hoof a popular pick on Amazon but it is also a favorite among our panelists. With a blend of hydrating ingredients like glycerin, urea and jojoba oil and purported strengthening ingredients like silk and calcium, this cream "strengthens and moisturizes," one panelist commented. For best results, apply three times a day to keep hands and nails quenched.
Pros
- Pink tint to combat discoloration
- Strengthens nails
Cons
It may look like a polish, but Orly's treatment claims to strengthen nails with "collagen, wheat protein, keratin and bamboo extract" while imparting a sheer pink tint to nails. "Orly makes my nails stronger without making them brittle and too hard," one panelist commented. Apply one to two coats daily and remove completely after seven days for best results.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Prevents breakage
- Makes nails feel harder
Cons
A formaldehyde-free version of OPI Nail Envy, another panel favorite, this strengthener contains several nail-shielding ingredients to prevent breakage, plus softening kukui nut oil. Apply two coats the first day and one every other day for best results.
Pros
- Hydrating serum
- Hardening base coat
Cons
- Expensive
This two-step kit includes a nail serum and a base coat that work together to improve the overall appearance of peeling nails. The serum first conditions nails with ingredients like plant-based oils and extracts while the base coat, applied on top of the serum once it's absorbed, gives nails strength.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Protective coating
- Double duty base coat
Cons
Essie's double-duty formula is a strengthening base coat, meant to be applied under your nail lacquer. "I like it because it is a 2-in-1 product that combines strengthening benefits along with my base coat, so I don’t need a separate step," one panelist commented. If using it solo, the brand recommends applying two coats.
Pros
- Tinted to combat discoloration
- Shields nails from damage
Cons
This nail treatment from Dermelect contains film-forming polymers to seal nails against damage and light pink pigment to conceal any discoloration. “It adds a sheer wash of color while helping my nails,” one panelist commented. The product claims to “replenish hydration to dry, brittle nails” with Pentavitin (Saccharide Isomerate).
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Sweetly scented
- Long lasting
Cons
- Requires a four week commitment
Unlike other strengtheners, ella + mila is scented with a sweet fragrance that has notes of watermelon and the formula “lasts longer than others," a panelist commented. This product does require a four-week commitment for best results, applied once per week for two weeks and then increased to every three days for another two weeks.
Pros
- Nourishes skin and nails
- Helps nails look healthy
Cons
The key to keeping brittle nails strong is to keep them hydrated with an efficacious hand cream, like this GH Beauty lab test-winning formula from Eucerin, containing key ingredients like urea and lactic acid. This nourishing cream contains both and was the best hand cream in our recent study, increasing skin hydration by 51% over six hours.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11
Best Nail Strengthener for Brittle Nails
Nail-Aid Sapphire Strength Mega Growth Nail Polish
Now 25% Off
Pros
- Durable coating
- Strengthens nails
Cons
This clear, glossy Nail-Aid nail strengthener contains calcium, which is purported to strengthen nails. It imparts a "strong coating and helps make nails stronger," a panelist commented. Brush two coats onto nails allowing each coat to completely dry before applying the next, using every three days for longer-lasting protection.
What's the most effective nail strengthener?
Nail strengthening treatments and hand creams can help with brittleness and keep nails looking strong and healthy. Here are your options:
✔️ Strengthening varnishes, which leave a shiny, hard coating on nails, enforces tips, making them appear thicker and can protect against damage.
✔️ Serum-like strengtheners absorb quickly and typically contain moisturizers to rehydrate dry, brittle nails.
✔️ Hand creams contain humectant ingredients, like urea and lactic acid, emollients such as lanolin, and occlusives like mineral oil and petrolatum, which work in tandem to enhance the hydration of both nails and skin.
And when selecting a nail strengthener, avoid formaldehyde. "Formaldehyde will initially harden nail but over time, the nail becomes paradoxically brittle and the ingredient can also cause severe allergic reactions," says Dana Stern, M.D., a dermatologist in New York City and nail expert for Nu Skin.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Why trust Good Housekeeping?
With a background in color cosmetic development, Danusia Wnek, a chemist in the Beauty, Health & Sustainability Lab, spends hours in the cosmetic aisles at pharmacies or in makeup retailers researching the newest makeup launches for upcoming studies. She has spent years evaluating nail polishes and nail treatments in the Lab and with consumers. For this piece, she polled our 1,300 panelists to gain a better understanding of consumer nail care habits and review their favorite nail strengtheners.
Danusia Wnek
Senior Chemist
Danusia (she/her) is a senior chemist in the Beauty, Health and Sustainability Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute where she evaluates haircare, skincare, cosmetics and beauty tools. She holds a B.S. in chemistry from St. John’s University and a M.S. in pharmaceutical sciences with concentration in cosmetic science from the University of Cincinnati. Danusia has over 10 years of experience in the personal care industry including formulation, product development, claim evaluation and efficacy testing.